Navigating Appraisal Challenges in Today's Real Estate Market

Josh Perez • September 4, 2024

As an appraiser, one of the most frequent questions I receive in today's market is whether we're seeing a lot of purchase activity and how appraisal values are holding up against the prices buyers are paying. The truth is, it varies depending on the area and the type of property, but certain trends are becoming increasingly clear.

"I've seen a lot of issues with value, and I'm sure you've experienced some of those issues with me, where purchasers might've paid 1.3 million at the height of the market and now their appraisals coming in at 1.1 or even less sometimes."

One area where we're seeing consistent issues is with new builds. Homes that were purchased at the peak of the market, particularly in 2021 or early 2022, are now facing challenges when it comes to appraisal values. The market has shifted, and in some cases, the price that buyers paid a year or two ago simply doesn't align with the current appraised value.


This discrepancy is particularly pronounced in specific developments, especially in areas where housing developments have sprung up in less traditionally desirable locations, such as Caledonia or Paris. These are places where people might not have wanted to live a few years ago, but due to urban expansion, they found themselves purchasing homes. Unfortunately, these buyers are now finding that the homes they purchased for $1.3 million at the market's height are being appraised at $1.1 million or even less.


When it comes to appraisals, several factors come into play, such as proximity to comparable homes, square footage, and lot size. However, these elements can vary in importance depending on the type of property. For single-family homes, the lot size is often a significant factor, whereas for investor properties or multifamily homes, the number of rooms may take precedence over square footage or lot size.


Interestingly, while the specifics might vary, there's not much variation from lender to lender regarding how these factors are considered. Adjustments in appraisal values are based on open market evidence, and certain features, like in-ground pools, tend to have a consistent impact on value regardless of the individual circumstances. For example, a mid-range home with a pool might see a $50,000 difference compared to one without, while a luxury home could see a shift of $75,000 to $100,000.



In conclusion, navigating the current real estate market can be challenging, especially when it comes to understanding how appraisal values stack up against purchase prices. As we continue to see shifts in the market, it's essential for buyers and investors to stay informed and work closely with their appraisers to ensure they have a clear understanding of the factors that could impact their property's value.

Josh Perez
GET STARTED

What You Need to Know About Mortgages and Parental Leave

By Josh Perez • July 8, 2026
If the title of this article caught your attention, chances are your family is growing. Congratulations. If you’re thinking now is the right time to move into a home that better fits your growing family—but you’re unsure how parental leave affects your ability to qualify for a mortgage—you’re in the right place. Here’s the good news. Qualifying for a mortgage while on parental leave is possible when it’s done correctly. When you work with an independent mortgage professional, lenders can often qualify you based on your return-to-work income , as long as you can provide documentation confirming you have guaranteed employment waiting for you. A word of caution If you walk into a bank branch and disclose that you’re currently on parental leave, there’s a chance the bank will only allow you to qualify using your parental leave income. That can significantly reduce your borrowing power. Parental leave income is typically limited to 55% of your previous earnings, up to a weekly maximum. Qualifying on that amount alone can restrict your options and impact the type of home you can purchase. Why lender choice matters One of the biggest advantages of working with an independent mortgage professional is choice . You’re not limited to one lender’s rules or products. Some lenders will allow you to qualify using 100% of your confirmed return-to-work income , which can make a meaningful difference in your approval amount and overall options. What you’ll need to qualify Most lenders will require an employment letter that includes: Employer name (preferably on company letterhead) Your job title Original start date (to confirm probation has been completed) Confirmed return-to-work date Guaranteed salary upon return Lenders want reassurance that your income will resume once parental leave ends. You may also be asked to provide income history from the past couple of years, which is standard for most mortgage applications. One important note Whether or not you actually return to work after parental leave is entirely your decision. From a mortgage perspective, qualification is based on having a confirmed position available to you at the time of approval. If you have questions about qualifying for a mortgage while on parental leave—or anything mortgage-related—please connect anytime. I’d be happy to walk you through your options and help you plan with confidence.
Suburban two-story house with a front porch, two-car garage, and a large tree-lined lawn.

Gifted Down Payment in Ontario? Don't Skip This Step

By Josh Perz • July 7, 2026
Using a gifted down payment to buy a home in Ontario? Learn exactly what lenders require — and the common mistakes that can delay or derail your approval.