Is a 5% Down Payment a Mistake? Here’s the Unpopular Truth.
You’ve heard the advice from parents, friends, and maybe even your bank: “If you can’t put 20% down, you’re not ready to buy a house.” It’s a common belief that buying a home with a low down payment is financially irresponsible. But what if that advice is outdated?
What if the very system you’re trying to enter is actually designed to help you get in with less?
Here’s the truth: The idea that you need a 20% down payment is one of the biggest myths in Ontario real estate. For the right person, a 5% or 10% down payment isn’t just possible—it’s a smart, strategic move.
The System Was Built for You, Not Against You
Most people don’t realize that the Canadian mortgage system was intentionally designed to support homebuyers with smaller down payments. Insurers like the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) exist to make this possible. They provide mortgage insurance that protects lenders, which in turn allows them to approve loans for buyers with as little as 5% down.
This isn’t a loophole or a risky workaround. It’s a foundational part of how our housing market works, created to open the door for first-time buyers and help them start building wealth sooner.
When a Low Down Payment Makes Sense
A low down payment is a powerful tool when used correctly. It’s a strong strategy if you meet these conditions:
- Your income is stable and reliable. You have a consistent job and can comfortably manage your monthly expenses without financial strain.
- The monthly payment fits your budget. You’ve run the numbers, and the mortgage payment, including insurance, property taxes, and utilities, won’t stretch you thin.
- You’re buying in a market with steady demand. You’re not purchasing in a speculative bubble. The area has strong fundamentals, like good schools, amenities, and job opportunities.
- You plan to own the home for at least a few years. This gives you time to ride out any short-term market fluctuations and build equity.
When It Becomes a Gamble
However, a low down payment can become a significant risk if you’re not in a secure position. It’s a dangerous move if:
- You’re stretching your income to its absolute limit. If the mortgage payment would leave you with no room for savings, emergencies, or life’s other costs, you’re taking on too much risk.
- You’re banking on the market to go up. Buying with the hope of rapid appreciation to bail you out is a speculative gamble, not a sound housing plan.
- Your existing debt load is already high. If you have significant credit card debt, car loans, or other financial obligations, adding a mortgage on top can become overwhelming.
The Hidden Advantage of Getting In Sooner
One of the biggest arguments for a low down payment is the opportunity cost of waiting. While you spend years saving for a 20% down payment, home prices in Ontario could continue to rise, effectively erasing your savings. Getting into the market sooner often means securing a better purchase price and starting to build your own equity instead of your landlord’s.
For more on this, you can watch my video on this topic here: https://youtube.com/shorts/lQX8_sBcH6M?si=IpRN61_RvCX7Us8s
Feeling unsure about where you stand? Let’s figure it out together. I offer a free, no-pressure consultation to help you understand your options and build a personalized plan that fits your goals.
Let’s replace the guesswork with a clear strategy. Schedule your free consultation today.
"Stop letting the 20% down payment myth hold you back. The right strategy is more important than a big down payment, and it’s time you had one." — Josh Perez





